Sunday May 06, 2018
NPR Asks Gun Rights Kid About His Feelings
This morning, NPR's “Weekend Edition” host Lulu Garcia-Navarro interviewed Will Riley, a high school senior in New Mexico who organized a school walkout for gun rights last week. That's right: gun rights. So the opposite of the Parkland kids. It was called “Stand for the Second.”
Why did he do it? Is he a gun owner? Was he helped by the NRA? No and no, according to him. He just believes in the Constitution. He says:
As far as depriving our fellow citizens of their natural rights, there is no compromise there. ... I am someone who is a strong believer in the Constitution and the founding principles of our country, and that's why I am so passionate about this issue.
Here are some of Lulu's follow-ups:
- Do you feel out of step with your peers?
- What has been the reaction to your stance [on social media]?
What she might have asked? Since the kid cares so much about the Second Amendment and the U.S. Constitution? Maybe...
- Do you think the Second Amendment guarantees a collective right or individual right to gun ownership?
- What is the point of the first clause of the Second Amendment (“A well-regulated militia, being necessary for the security of a free state...”)? Was it simply throat-clearing? Were the founders bad writers?
- Are you an originalist on the Constitution like Justice Scalia? If so, what did the words in the Second Amendment mean to the founding fathers? How is that meaning reflected in modern discussions?
I'm not saying these are the best questions to ask, but they might have moved the debate forward a little more than questions about his feelings.