Hollywood B.O.: The Growing Link Between Box Office and Rotten Tomato Scores
Last night on RottenTomatoes.com, while checking out a slideshow ranking 2012 summer movies by RT score, I noticed how much the rankings correlated with box office. In 2008, on Slate, I argued just that. I.e., quality (as seen by RT rating) tends to equal quantity (in box office $$), particularly when you attempt to sort out variables such as viewing opportunities.
Here's the list of the summer movies of 2012, with Rotten Tomatoes ratings and rankings, but ranked by summer box office. (A red RT rating means it's fresh: 60% or more critics liked it):
|RT rating||RT rank||BO Rank||Movie||Box Office||Thtrs||Open||Close|
|92%||2||1||Marvel's The Avengers||$617,814,000||4,349||4-May||-|
|87%||3||2||The Dark Knight Rises||$422,188,000||4,404||20-Jul||-|
|73%||10||3||The Amazing Spider-Man||$258,364,000||4,318||3-Jul||-|
|75%||9||6||Madagascar 3: Europe's Most Wanted||$213,689,000||4,263||8-Jun||-|
|48%||25||8||Snow White and the Huntsman||$154,920,000||3,777||1-Jun||-|
|39%||30||9||Ice Age: Continental Drift||$153,409,000||3,886||13-Jul||-|
|55%||20||12||The Bourne Legacy||$85,500,000||3,753||10-Aug||-|
|21%||38||15||Tyler Perry's Madea's Witness Protection||$65,044,500||2,161||29-Jun||-|
|31%||34||18||Total Recall (2012)||$55,263,000||3,601||3-Aug||-|
|66%||16||19||The Expendables 2||$52,314,000||3,355||17-Aug||-|
|48%||24||23||Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days||$42,863,000||3,401||3-Aug||-|
|23%||35||24||What to Expect When You're Expecting||$41,152,203||3,021||18-May||2-Aug|
|41%||28||25||Rock of Ages||$38,518,613||3,470||15-Jun||16-Aug|
|35%||32||26||Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter||$37,344,398||3,109||22-Jun||-|
|22%||36||27||That's My Boy||$36,931,089||3,030||15-Jun||22-Jul|
|43%||27||28||Step Up Revolution||$33,709,000||2,606||27-Jul||-|
|38%||31||31||The Odd Life of Timothy Green||$27,080,000||2,598||15-Aug||-|
|77%||7||32||Katy Perry: Part of Me||$25,311,000||2,732||5-Jul||-|
|57%||19||35||People Like Us||$12,422,529||2,055||29-Jun||-|
|52%||23||36||Seeking a Friend for the End of the World||$7,078,738||1,625||22-Jun||5-Jul|
|44%||26||38||Hit and Run||$5,868,000||2,870||22-Aug||-|
|16%||40||39||For Greater Glory||$5,672,846||757||1-Jun||16-Aug|
|7%||42||40||Nitro Circus the Movie 3D||$3,300,000||800||8-Aug||-|
Of the 43 summer movies listed, 17 were rated fresh. These include the seven highest-grossing films of the summer, and nine of the top 11. The highest-grossing film, “The Avengers,” had the second-highest RT score. The second highest-grossing film, “The Dark Knight Rises,” had the third-highest RT score.
Of the fresh films, the anomalies were the August releases (“Premium Rush,” “ParaNorman,” “Hope Springs,” “The Expendables 2”), which perhaps haven't had their box-office due yet; the auteur films (“Moonrise Kingdom,” “Cosmopolis”), which were distributed accordingly (i.e., parsimoniously); and “Katy Perry: Part of Me,” which, apparently, moviegoers just didn't care to see.
Of the rotten films, the true overperformers were “Snow White and the Huntsman,” which finished 8th for the summer; and “Tyler Perry's Madea's Witness Protection,” which, as a Tyler Perry movie, is virtually critic-proof.
The other rotten films? Underperformers. “Ice Age” grossed the least of the “Ice Age” franchise, “The Bourne Legacy” grossed the least of the “Bourne” franchise, and potential tentpole films like “Battleship” and “Total Recall” folded up opening weekend.
Basically, if a movie was deemed good on RottenTomatoes, and was readily available, moviegoers went to see it. Exactly as I stated in 2008.
In fact, it's truer today than it was then. My article focused on 2007, a year in which box office was dominated by lame and generally rotten sequels such as “Spider-Man 3,” “Shrek the Third,” and the third “Pirates of the Caribbean” movie. Now box office is dominated by films RT has deemed fresh.
I don't know if this is part of a trend. I don't know if moviegoers are using sites such as RT, or social media, in order to figure out—possibly at the theater—which movies to go see. Would be cool if it were true.
Or could RT critics be tailoring their reviews for summer blockbusters? “These are the popular movies and so I must judge them accordingly?” Would be a drag if that were true.
But how else to explain 69% for “MIB 3,” 66% for “The Campaign” and, back in 2007, 62% for effin' “Spider-Man 3,” one of the worst superhero movies ever made? Could it be that, just as there's carryover in box office from a good film to a bad sequel, so there's carryover in RT numbers? Critics say, “Not as good as ... but you'll have a good time ...”? That would certainly explain the 87% rating for “Dark Knight Rises,” the third highest-ranked film of the summer, which had its share of problems. As even fanboys have admitted. (HISHE: Still waiting on “How 'Ted' Should Have Ended.”)
Bottom line: If you saw “Moonrise Kingdom” and “The Avengers” this summer, you won.
And the children shall lead. The top three summer 2012 movies as ranked by Rotten Tomatoes: an adult's view of kids, and kids' views of adults.
Movie Reviews - 2013
Movie Reviews - 2012
Movie Reviews - 2011
Movie Reviews - 2010
Movie Reviews - 2009
Movie Reviews - 2000s
Movie Reviews - 1990s
Movie Reviews - 1980s
Movie Reviews - 1970s
Movie Reviews - 1960s
Movie Reviews - 1950s
Movie Reviews - 1940s
Movie Reviews - 1930s
Movie Reviews - 1920s
Movies - Box Office
Movies - Documentaries
Movies - Foreign
Movies - The Oscars
Movies - Scene of the Day
Movies - Studios
Movies - Theaters
Movies - Trailers
Quote of the Day
What Liberal Hollywood?
Box Office Mojo
The Film Experience
Large Ass Movie Blogs