Monday June 22, 2009
Dumb like a Fox
Last week, John Lesher, the president of the Paramount Film Group, was fired and replaced by Adam Goodman, former head of production at Dreamworks SKG. Nikki Finke’s blog listed a number of offenses against Lesher, including drunkenness, while the L.A. Times said his biggest offense in his 18 months on the job wasn’t greenlighting enough pictures.
Maybe the two are related. I have no idea—I’m way the hell up in Seattle, and I don’t read much on internal studio dynamics—but the following, at least, demonstrates a problem Paramount has had for the last five years. It’s a table on how the big six studios (plus DreamWorks) fared with their superwide (3,000+ theater) releases from 2004 to 2008, ranked by average box office:
Superwide Releases, 2004-2008, by Studio/Distributor
Studio |
No. films |
"Fresh" films* |
% of "fresh" films |
Avg. box office |
DreamWorks/Paramount |
12 |
7 |
58% |
$153,894,953 |
Buena Vista |
36 |
11 |
30% |
$132,481,548 |
Warner Bros. |
38 |
15 |
39% |
$128,921,554 |
DreamWorks |
10 |
5 |
50% |
$125,634,867 |
Universal |
19 |
7 |
37% |
$119,575,789 |
Sony |
30 |
8 |
26% |
$113,209,160 |
Paramount |
22 |
11 |
50% |
$105,187,877 |
Fox |
39 |
6 |
15% |
$103,167,684 |
If you’re a regular reader you know I’m someone who believes that, with similar movies, good generally beats bad. People are more likely to go see a good popcorn movie over a bad one, and an exciting arthouse movie over a dull one. To paraphrase a famous movie line: “If you build it well, they will come.”
Paramount, according to this chart, builds them better than most, but, on average, fewer people show up.
The bigger question the table raises, though, is this: What’s up with Fox? They have the lowest percentage of fresh films and the lowest average box office per film as well. If you’re wondering what Fox's 39 superwide releases over the last five years look like, here you go. As sorted by top-critics-ranking on Rotten Tomatoes:
Fox's Superwide Releases: 2004-2008
Film |
Top Critics' Ranking (RT) |
Dom. Box Office |
Horton Hears a Who |
81% | $154m |
The Simpsons Movie |
81% | $183m |
Live Free or Die Hard |
78% | $134m |
Robots |
69% | $128m |
Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith |
69% | $380m |
Ice Age: The Meltdown |
62% | $195m |
Because of Winn-Dixie |
53% | $32m |
Nim's Island |
52% | $48m |
Fever Pitch |
51% | $42m |
Marley & Me |
50% | $143m |
X-Men: The Last Stand |
50% | $234m |
I, Robot |
50% | $144m |
Kingdom of Heaven |
50% | $47m |
Mr. & Mrs. Smith |
43% | $186m |
Transporter 2 |
42% | $43m |
The Day After Tomorrow |
41% | $186m |
Night at the Museum |
39% | $250m |
Meet Dave |
37% | $11m |
Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium |
37% | $32m |
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer |
31% | $131m |
What Happens in Vegas |
30% | $80m |
Fantastic Four |
27% | $154m |
The X-Files: I Want to Believe |
25% | $20m |
27 Dresses |
23% | $76m |
Alvin and the Chipmunks |
22% | $217m |
Taxi |
19% | $36m |
Hide and Seek |
18% | $51m |
Big Momma's House 2 |
13% | $70m |
Elektra |
13% | $24m |
Cheaper by the Dozen 2 |
12% | $82m |
The Day the Earth Stood Still |
12% | $79m |
Eragon |
11% | $75m |
The Seeker: The Dark is Rising |
11% | $8m |
Garfield: The Movie |
9% | $75m |
Max Payne |
9% | $40m |
Deck the Halls |
9% | $35m |
Alien vs. Predator |
4% | $80m |
Jumper |
3% | $80m |
Babylon A.D. |
0% | $22m |
It’s not pretty. I liked, well enough, “Mr. & Mrs. Smith,” “The Simpsons Movie” and “Marley and Me,” but there’s no standout film here, and most of their menu smells like the glop of McDonald’s. In fact, they’re the only major studio over the last five years not to release a film superwide that garnered a 90% or better rating from the top critics in the country. DreamWorks (“Wallace and Gromit”) Paramount (“Iron Man”) and Universal (“The Bourne Ultimatum”) each did it once; Sony did it twice (“Casino Royale”; “Spider-Man 2”); Warner Bros. three times (“The Dark Knight”; “The Departed”; “Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban”); and Buena Vista, with a big helping hand from Pixar, did it four times (“Ratatouille”; “WALL-E”; “The Incredibles” and “Enchanted”). Fox? Nothing. Not even close. As you can see.
Equally astonishing is the kinds of movies Fox decides to dump into 3,000+ theaters. “The Seeker”? “Meet Dave”? “Elektra”? The preeminent popular genre of the decade is the superhero film and what has Fox done with it? They’ve taken one franchise that started brilliantly (Bryan Singer’s “X-Men”) and run it into the ground, while taking one of the more famous superhero teams ever created (“The Fantastic Four”) and never got it off the ground. You could argue that Fox’s most successful superhero over the past five years isn’t Wolverine or Mr. Fantastic; it’s Spider-Pig.
In the 1930s studios had personalities. Warner Bros. was gritty gangster stuff, MGM went after glamour and sophistication, etc. Studios are corporate-run now—smaller entities within larger multinational conglomerates—so we no longer ascribe a personality to their output. Lucky for Fox.
Baseball's Active Leaders, 2023
What Trump Said When About COVID
Recent Reviews
Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022)
Black Panther: Wakanda Forever (2022)
Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness (2022)
Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021)
The Cagneys
A Midsummer Night's Dream (1935)
Something to Sing About (1937)
Angels with Dirty Faces (1938)
A Lion Is In the Streets (1953)
Man of a Thousand Faces (1957)
Never Steal Anything Small (1959)
Shake Hands With the Devil (1959)