ErikLundegaard.com - Ben Affleck Wins DGA

Ben Affleck Wins DGA

The line from the Directors Guild of America Award for best director to the Oscar for best director to the Oscar for best picture has been fairly straight over the years.

In the 1990s, we had two stumbles: Ron Howard (“Apollo 13”) won the DGA but he wasn't nom'ed for the Oscar. As a result, the Oscar's best director and best picture went to Mel Gibson and “Braveheart” instead. Then in 1998, Steven Spielberg won both the DGA and the Oscar for best director but his picture, “Saving Private Ryan,” in one of the greatest upsets in Oscar history (engineered by Harvey Weinstein, of course), went to “Shakesepare in Love.” Blah.

In the first decade of the 21st century, we had even more stumbles. 2000 was all over the place: Ang Lee (“Crouching Tiger”) got the Directors Guild of America logo (DGA) DGA, Steve Soderbergh (“Traffic”) got the Oscar, but the best pic went to “Gladiator.” In 2002, Rob Marshall (“Chicago”) got the DGA, and his picture, “Chicago,” got the Oscar, but the best director Oscar went, deservedly to Roman Polanski (“The Pianist”). Then there was the mess of 2005: DGA and Oscar to Ang Lee for “Brokeback Mountain,” best pic to “Crash.” Don't get me started on that one.

Since? The line hasn't been broken.

This year it will be. The winner of the DGA tonight was Ben Affleck for “Argo”; and since he hasn't been nominated for an Oscar for best director, it's gotta go to someone else—most likely Steven Spielberg.

As for best picture then?

Well, the last time a director won the DGA and hadn't been nominated for an Oscar was Ron Howard in 1995. Mel Gibson and “Braveheart” were the beneficiaries that year. Could Spielberg and “Lincoln” be the beneficiaries this year? No pun intended on “ben.”

On the other hand, since the advent of the SAG-cast award in 1996, any movie that won all three of the guilds won the Oscar for best picture: “The King's Speech,” “Slumdog Millionaire,” “No Country for Old Men,” “Lord of the Rings: Return of the King,” “Chicago,” and “American Beauty.”

Here's the guild history:

Year	DGA	PGA	SAG - CAST
2012	Argo	Argo	Argo
2011	The Artist	The Artist	The Help
2010	The King's Speech	The King's Speech	The King's Speech
2009	The Hurt Locker	The Hurt Locker	Inglourious Bastards
2008	Slumdog Millionaire	Slumdog Millionaire	Slumdog Millionaire
2007	No Country for Old Men	No Country for Old Men	No Country for Old Men
2006	The Departed	Little Miss Sunshine	Little Miss Sunshine
2005	Brokeback Mountain	Brokeback Mountain	Crash
2004	Million Dollar Baby	The Aviator	Sideways
2003	Lord of the Rings	Lord of the Rings	Lord of the Rings
2002	Chicago	Chicago	Chicago
2001	A Beautiful Mind	Moulin Rouge!	Gosford Park
2000	Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon	Gladiator	Traffic
1999	American Beauty	American Beauty	American Beauty
1998	Saving Private Ryan	Saving Private Ryan	Shakespeare in Love
1997	Titanic	Titanic	The Full Monty
1996	The English Patient	The English Patient	The Birdcage
1995	Apollo 13	Apollo 13
1994	Forrest Gump	Forrest Gump
1993	Schindler's List	Schindler's List
1992	Unforgiven	The Crying Game
1991	Silence of the Lambs	The Silence of the Lambs
1990	Dances with Wolves	Dances with Wolves
1989	Born on the 4th of July	Driving Miss Daisy

Elsewhere in the night, “Searching for Sugar Man” won the DGA for best documentary, Jay Roach won for best movie on television (“Game Change”), and Milos Forman won the lifetime achievement award.

My early bet is split vote: Spielberg and “Argo.” But what do I know? I'm in Seattle.

Ben Affleck in "Argo" (2012)