erik lundegaard

 RSS    Facebook
ARCHIVES
By Category
General
Baseball
Biking
Books
Business
Culture
Hiking
Jean Gabin
Jordy’s Reviews
Lancelot Links
The Media
Microsoft
Movies
Movies - Box Office
Movies - Foreign
Movies - The Oscars
Movies - Reviews
Movies - Reviews - 2010
Movies - Studios
Movies - Theaters
Movies - Trailers
Music
Personal Pieces
Politics
Quote of the Day
Robin Hood
J.D. Salinger
Seattle
Seattle Mariners
Superheroes
TV
Vietnam
What Liberal Hollywood?
Word Study
Yankees Suck
By Month
March 2010
February 2010
October 2009
June 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
October 2008
February 2008

All previous entries

LINKS
Movies
Roger Ebert
David Edelstein
Film Experience Blog
Patrick Goldstein
Dave Kehr
Large Ass Movie Blogs
Le Monde
Northwest Film Forum
James Rocchi
Jeffrey Wells
Politics
Eric Alterman
Hendrik Hertzberg
Clay Shirky
Andrew Sullivan
Tom Toles
Baseball
Rob Neyer
USS Mariner
Joe Posnanski
Friends
Deb Ellis
Andrew Engelson
Tim Harrison
Jessica Thompson
Uncle Vinny
Wednesday June 24, 2009

And the nominees are...doubled

At least according to this Variety report. Beginning next year, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences will nominate 10 best picture candidates rather than the five they've been nominating since 1944.

Some may applaud the move. It certainly gives the "Dark Knight"s of the world a better chance to show up. But the Academy is messing with tradition, and for a seemingly short-term gain in ratings and relevance.

My immediate reaction? Feels desperate.

More here.

And here.

UPDATE: It's 10 minutes later and the whole thing smells. The major studios, which can't make best pictures anymore, want their pictures nominated "best" nonetheless. The Academy, which can't seem to nominate popular and critically acclaimed pictures like "Dark Knight" and "WALL-E," wants relevance and ratings. This is the compromise. But it's a bad one. I remember baseball player Keith Hernandez arguing once that you only mess with tradition if the new rules increase strategy. That's why he was in favor of the three-point play in basketball and against the DH in baseball. The former increased strategy, the latter decreased it. Here? It dilutes it. Ten nominees means there will be more flotsam ("Frost/Nixon") and jetsam ("The Reader") in the race; stuff to push aside to get at the real race.

Bottom line: they're fixing something that's not broken (the five nominee slots) because of something that is (the major studios don't make best pictures anymore). What a shame.

Posted at 11:48 AM on Jun 24, 2009 in category Movies - The Oscars
1 Comment   |   Permalink