Movie Reviews - 2013
Movie Reviews - 2012
Movie Reviews - 2011
Movie Reviews - 2010
Movie Reviews - 2009
Movie Reviews - 2000s
Movie Reviews - 1990s
Movie Reviews - 1980s
Movie Reviews - 1970s
Movie Reviews - 1960s
Movie Reviews - 1950s
Movie Reviews - 1940s
Movie Reviews - 1930s
Movie Reviews - 1920s
Movies - Box Office
Movies - Documentaries
Movies - Foreign
Movies - The Oscars
Movies - Scene of the Day
Movies - Studios
Movies - Theaters
Movies - Trailers
Quote of the Day
What Liberal Hollywood?
Box Office Mojo
The Film Experience
Large Ass Movie Blogs
The secret to Tyler Perry’s success
In June 2006, when the bulk of papers belonging to Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. were about to be auctioned at Sotheby’s and possibly into private hands, Mayor Shirley Franklin and the city of Atlanta pre-empted the bidding with a $32 million offer — ensuring that the papers stayed both in the city and for the public. According to the New York Times, Ms. Franklin accomplished this by calling in favors from Atlanta bigwigs. Three were mentioned up front: Delta Airlines, Coca-Cola and Tyler Perry.
Let me repeat that: Delta Airlines, Coca-Cola and Tyler Perry. Two international corporations... and a playwright who was homeless a decade ago.
Shocking the industry
I’ve been intrigued by Tyler Perry since February 2005 when the film based upon one of his hugely successful plays, “Diary of a Mad Black Woman,” was savaged by critics and went to No. 1 at the box office. This equation — snubbed by critics, big bucks — describes practically every weekend at the modern box office, but most box-office winners are sleek corporate products, blockbusters and niche films, buoyed by marketing and product tie-ins. They’re top-down films.
“Diary” was a bottom-up film. Because of Perry’s theater work he had the support of a constituency long ago ignored by Hollywood — black church crowds — and they came out en masse for “Diary.” So even though the film screened in fewer theaters (1,483) than any other film in the top 10, it trumped them all and, as they say, shocked the industry.
A year later, Perry succeeded again with “Madea’s Family Reunion.” And while “Daddy’s Little Girls” underperformed in February 2007, Perry showed he could make it without Madea and outside of black history month when “Why Did I Get Married?” debuted at No. 1 last October.
Two more of his movies are being released this year: “Meet the Browns” this week and “The Family that Preys” in September.
For most of these films, Perry writes them (from his already successful plays), stars in them (usually in multiple roles), produces and directs them. They are wholly his. But what are they?
Trying the patience of Job
I’d characterize them this way: opulent soap operas with overt Christian messages and comic relief along the edges.
The plot? There’s usually an impossibly bad man (Charles, Carlos, Mike), who is physically and mentally abusive to the heroine.
There’s usually an impossible good man (Orlando, Frankie, Sheriff Troy), a handsome Christian with a working-class job and artistic aspirations, who helps and passively loves the heroine.
Since the outcome to this dilemma is obvious, the “drama,” such as it is, lies in keeping the heroine with the impossibly bad man and away from the impossibly good man for as long as possible. This is done by making the woman a doormat (Helen in “Diary”) or a martyr (Sheila in “Married”). They either have the patience of Job... or they’re so dumb as to try the patience of Job.
Look at “Diary.” In the beginning, Helen (Kimberly Elise) admits that after 18 years of marriage, her husband, Charles (Steve Harris), has become a stranger to her. Then after Charles is crushingly cruel to her, she says in voiceover: “Why do I love this man so much?”
We don’t know. He’s having an affair. That’s not enough. She comes home to a U-Haul in the driveway and all new clothes — that don’t quite fit — in her closet. The other shoe doesn’t drop. When he confronts her with the other woman, she still won’t leave and has to be physically dragged from their mansion. She returns to her estranged family (Madea and company), and they give divine rationale for leaving her husband and standing on her own. She resists. The impossibly nice man keeps helping. She resists him, too. Basically she is as resistant to accepting the good as she is in leaving the bad.
But at some point in all of Perry’s films, there’s a violent, worm-turns moment. So Sheila breaks a bottle over Mike’s head (“Married?”) and Lisa throws hot grits on Carlos (“Family Reunion”), and, in the most disturbing example, Helen returns to Charles, now paralyzed, and abuses him. It’s pretty sadistic stuff. Perry’s characters often say “Lord have mercy” and you wonder if it’s because his characters have so little.
Perry himself was physically abused by his father, and he spent his early adult life coming to terms with that abuse until he was able to forgive the man — and by extension himself — and this is the arc of his films: abuse, revenge, forgiveness through the grace of God. The heroine is then able to live her life fully while the impossibly bad man sinks into repentance. It’s an Oprah wish-fulfillment moment. It’s “The Color Purple.”
And it’s the secret to his success.
The great conflict in American art
But something more important is going on, too.
In his films the comic relief is provided by the older generation — the straight-talking, gun-toting, nurturing grandma, Madea (Perry in drag), and her straight-talking, flatulent brother Joe (Perry again) — and not only are these characters more entertaining, they point out what’s historically relevant about Perry’s work.
The great conflict in American art and life is the assimilationist conflict: tensions between Old World and New, between immigrant parents and first-generation children, between a disappearing cultural authenticity and a bland, assimilated future. For most ethnic groups the dividing line is Ellis Island: We were this but we can become that. Forgetting what we were is part of the American dream.
—Erik Lundegaard already misses “The Wire.” This article was originally published 3/17/08 on MSNBC.com.